Milwaukee fans can begin to imagine it.
The final out. The celebration on the field. The phone calls to people who have waited for years to celebrate.
A World Series championship. Finally.
For Tampa Bay fans, the question is becoming a much less enjoyable one: What if another wonderful season ends just short of the championship?
The Brewers have taken control of a World Series that began with something unusual: neither franchise had ever won it all.
Nothing is settled until a team wins four games. But no team has ever come back from a 3–0 deficit to win the World Series.
The contrast between what these two fan bases are experiencing brings me to a question:
Would you rather have your team win one championship and spend most of the next 20 years outside contention—or enjoy 20 years of competitive teams and frequent playoff appearances without ever winning it all?
You have to choose.
No negotiating for a championship followed by a dynasty.
First, a confession
I’ve been fortunate.
Since becoming a sports fan in the late 1960s, I’ve celebrated championships by the Yankees, Knicks, football Giants and Rangers, along with my University of Michigan teams in football and basketball.
Some I experienced in person. Others I watched on television. The most meaningful memories bring back the people who shared them with me—my dad, my sons, friends.
So it’s easy for me to say there’s more to being a fan than winning championships. I’ve had plenty to celebrate.
Someone who has spent 50 years waiting for just one might reasonably tell me to try living on the other side.
Still, some of my favorite sports memories involve games that didn’t decide a championship.
Which is why I don’t think the answer is quite as obvious as it sounds.
Two teams trying to finish the story
Before this matchup, Milwaukee’s only World Series appearance came in 1982, when the Brewers lost to the St. Louis Cardinals in seven games.
The Rays reached the World Series in 2008 and again in 2020, losing to the Phillies and Dodgers.
This October brought Milwaukee back to the World Series for the first time in 44 years and Tampa Bay back for its third appearance.
Now Milwaukee is closing in on the ending its fans have waited so long to see. Tampa Bay is trying to keep that same dream alive.
But these teams also make an interesting case for the value of being competitive.
Both organizations have shown that a team can give its fans meaningful baseball without having the resources of the sport’s biggest spenders. They have built contenders, developed players and given their fans reasons to believe.
Those seasons mattered before either team reached this World Series.
If your team loses this time, does that erase everything you enjoyed getting here?
I would say no.
I also understand that “we had a wonderful season” might not be what you want to hear immediately after the final out.
The shrinking waiting list
Entering this World Series, five current MLB franchises had never won it:
Milwaukee Brewers
Tampa Bay Rays
Seattle Mariners
San Diego Padres
Colorado Rockies
When the Series ends, there will be four.
That’s a short list with a lot of waiting behind it.
And those fans haven’t all experienced the same kind of wait. Some have enjoyed stretches of excellent baseball. Others have endured years when the postseason seemed out of reach before summer really got started.
“Never won a World Series” describes the ultimate result.
It doesn’t describe the entire experience of following a team.
The case for taking the championship
As a Yankees fan, I still don’t particularly enjoy bringing up the 2001 World Series.
But Diamondbacks fans probably don’t mind.
Arizona won the championship in its fourth season, beating the Yankees in a Game 7 that gave its fans a memory they could keep forever.
The Diamondbacks haven’t won another World Series.
Would their fans trade that championship for more postseason appearances, knowing none would end with a title?
I suspect many would hold tightly to 2001.
A championship gives you something that can’t be taken away by the next losing season, a bad trade or the departure of your favorite player.
You can watch the highlights again. You can tell your children where you were.
You can say, “I saw it.”
For a Brewers or Rays fan who has never had that opportunity, the choice may be very easy.
The case for having a reason to watch
But there are a lot of games between championships.
Baseball asks you to invest in 162 of them before the postseason even begins.
A competitive team gives those months a different feeling. You check the standings over breakfast. You debate a pitching change with a friend. You stay up for the ninth inning because the result matters.
You look forward to tomorrow’s game.
That has value, too.
Would one glorious October make up for two decades of mostly meaningless Septembers?
Perhaps.
But I wouldn’t dismiss the fan who chooses years of anticipation, entertainment and hope—even knowing how the final chapter will end.
Baseball fans have plenty of company
Across the other sports, there are many fans who would welcome this dilemma.
Ten NBA franchises have never won an NBA championship:
Nets, Hornets, Pacers, Clippers, Grizzlies, Timberwolves, Pelicans, Magic, Suns and Jazz.
The Nets and Pacers did win ABA championships.
Twelve NFL franchises have never won a Super Bowl:
Cardinals, Falcons, Bills, Panthers, Bengals, Browns, Lions, Texans, Jaguars, Chargers, Vikings and Titans.
Several won earlier NFL or AFL championships, so “never won a Super Bowl” is an important distinction.
And 10 current NHL franchises have never won the Stanley Cup:
Sabres, Canucks, Senators, Sharks, Predators, Blue Jackets, Wild, Jets, Kraken and Utah Mammoth. The current Senators are separate from the original Ottawa franchise that won Cups.
Think about Buffalo’s four consecutive Super Bowl appearances.
Four extraordinary seasons. Four devastating endings.
Would Bills fans exchange those years for one championship surrounded by losing seasons?
It depends on where you’re sitting
Some of us have had considerably more opportunities to celebrate than others.
In one historical metropolitan-area tally of championships across the four major sports, the leaders are:
New York/New Jersey — 58
Boston — 40
Chicago — 29
Los Angeles/Anaheim — 27
Detroit — 22
Those figures include historical NFL championships and keep titles in the cities where they were won. Definitions vary among published rankings.
Of course, the Yankees’ championships don’t necessarily comfort a Mets fan.
And the Rays don’t get to borrow the Buccaneers’ or Lightning’s trophies. Neither do the Brewers get to count the Bucks’ championships as their own.
When it’s your team, the waiting is personal.
My answer—and yours
If you force me to choose, I lean toward the championship.
I know what it means to share one with people I love. I know how long those memories last.
But the older I get, the more I appreciate having something to look forward to—and people to enjoy it with.
A good team can give you that for months at a time.
For Milwaukee fans, the prospect of that first championship is becoming wonderfully real.
For Tampa Bay fans, appreciating the journey may be a harder assignment right now.
That’s understandable. Nobody watches a World Series hoping to collect a few pleasant memories and finish second.
But once the disappointment fades, does a fan wish the whole season away? The victories, the conversations, the nights spent watching with family and friends?
I wouldn’t.
I’d still want that final celebration, though.
So imagine you’re offered this deal:
One championship, followed by 20 years mostly outside contention.
Or 20 years of competitive teams and frequent playoff appearances—but no championship.
Which would you choose?
