A coach’s decision. An official’s call. A great comeback. A team that looked unbeatable a week ago and suddenly has some explaining to do.
I arrive with topics and questions. The fans bring their own.
By 10 o’clock on Tuesday mornings at Pelican Bay, there’s always plenty to talk about.
For the past year, I’ve had the pleasure of moderating Sports Talk at the Pelican Bay Community Center in Naples, Florida. We meet from 10 to 11 a.m., following Men’s Coffee, and welcome all Pelican Bay members, women and men.
On November 10, we’ll celebrate our first anniversary.
Looking back over the past year, I’m struck by how much ground we’ve covered—and how much I’ve enjoyed the give-and-take with the people in the room.
A conversation we build together
Our first meeting was November 4, 2025. Fifteen people attended. We introduced the idea, talked about the World Series, moved into professional and college football, and discussed FC Naples’ playoff run.
Since then, the sports calendar has given us a fresh agenda every week.
We’ve discussed highlight-reel plays and clutch moments, coaching changes, NFL draft choices, NIL and the transfer portal in college sports, Hall of Fame candidates, baseball’s automated ball-strike challenge system, the challenges of finding games across television and streaming packages, and the growing influence of artificial intelligence.
We’ve followed the Super Bowl, the World Series, the NBA Finals and the Stanley Cup playoffs, along with major championships in golf and tennis, the Winter Olympics, the World Baseball Classic and the World Cup.
But a list of topics only tells part of the story.
What makes the hour enjoyable is the exchange. I’ll raise a question, offer some context or share a perspective from my career. Someone will challenge the premise or take the discussion in a direction I hadn’t anticipated.
That gives me something to respond to—and often another question to ask.
I may moderate Sports Talk, but the people who attend help shape every session. Their interests, memories and opinions determine which subjects deserve another few minutes and which ones we can leave behind.
I’ve spent more than 40 years working in sports, media and technology. That gives me experiences to draw on. It also gives me an appreciation for a good follow-up question, including one directed at me.
The pleasure of a familiar room
There’s a particular enjoyment in having these conversations face-to-face.
You can hear the conviction in someone’s prediction and see the reaction across the room. You can ask, “Why do you think that?” and give the person time to explain. A disagreement can lead to a story, a laugh or a better understanding of another fan’s point of view.
And when you meet regularly, the conversation carries over.
Predictions can be revisited. Questions get another look. People become familiar with one another’s teams and loyalties.
You don’t need to know every statistic to participate. You can ask a question, share a memory, offer an opinion or simply listen. We want people to feel comfortable coming through the door.
Perspectives from inside the game
Guest speakers have added another dimension to our first year, giving us opportunities to ask questions of people whose experiences go well beyond watching from the stands.
Paralympic athlete Kendall Gretsch joined us in April. Her perspective brought us closer to the dedication and resilience that elite competition demands.
Former college football official Charles Horton helped us examine the game from the officiating crew’s point of view. Fans have plenty to say about officials; hearing from someone who has done the job adds useful context to those conversations.
Fred Katz, a former editor at SPORT magazine, shared his experiences covering sports and reflected on how sports journalism has changed. One session included a discussion of the magazine’s December 1969 cover featuring Wes Unseld, O.J. Simpson, Bobby Orr and Denny McLain—a starting point with plenty of possibilities.
Former PepsiCo executive Steve Liguori discussed his role in the transformation of the Super Bowl halftime show, including the move toward celebrity entertainment with Michael Jackson.
We also welcomed former NHL player Pat Boutette, who shared stories from his career, including playing alongside Gordie Howe with the Hartford Whalers.
Whether we’re hearing from a guest or debating among ourselves, there’s always someone with a question—or an answer.
Mel Poplock makes sure we work for some of those answers. A former chairman of the Southwest Florida chapter of the Society for American Baseball Research, Mel brings deep baseball knowledge and tests ours with his tough trivia contests.
I’m grateful for his contributions and for everyone who has helped make Tuesday mornings something to look forward to.
A celebration with opinions encouraged
For our November 10 anniversary celebration, we’re giving participants an opportunity to put their opinions to the test.
Short “Fan Speak-Out” segments will invite them to take a position and defend it. The planned subjects include Super Bowl predictions, baseball’s labor outlook and a question that should leave us with plenty to discuss: Who is the greatest athlete of all time? Mel will host an All-Star version of trivia, with prizes for the winners.
The celebration will take place from 10 to 11 a.m. at the Pelican Bay Community Center and is for Pelican Bay members only. I hope our regular participants will join us and that members who have been curious about Sports Talk will give it a try.
For me, it’s become a favorite part of the week: talking sports, hearing different perspectives and spending time with friends.
